Skip to content
Mobley Brothers Roofing & Renovation
White farmhouse with a silver metal roof and wraparound porch

Blog

Metal roof vs shingles: how to choose for your Tennessee home

Published May 19, 2021, updated October 21, 2026, Mobley Brothers team

When it is time for a new roof, more homeowners ask us about a metal roof vs shingles. Both will protect a home well when they are installed correctly, but they differ in upfront cost, lifespan, looks and upkeep.

When it is time for a new roof, more homeowners ask us about a metal roof vs shingles. Both will protect a home well when they are installed correctly, but they differ in upfront cost, lifespan, looks and upkeep. Mobley Brothers Roofing & Renovation installs both architectural asphalt shingles and metal roofing from our offices in Lebanon and Knoxville, so we have no reason to steer you toward one. Here is how we help homeowners think it through, plus the truth behind a few metal roofing myths.

Start with your neighborhood rules

Some neighborhoods and homeowners associations limit roofing materials, styles or colors. Before you fall in love with a metal roof, read your covenants or call your HOA. Some ban metal outright, some allow only certain profiles or colors, and some simply ask that the roof be approved before work starts. Knowing that first saves you from pricing a roof you cannot install.

Closer view of the roof: a single-story white ranch-style house with a dark shingle roof and brick chimney, surrounded by mature trees and green lawn, with a metal fence in the foregrou

Metal roof vs shingles: how long each one lasts

Lifespan is where the two materials differ most. InterNACHI's estimated life expectancy chart puts architectural asphalt shingles at around 30 years and metal roofing at roughly 40 to 80 years. Treat those as general industry estimates, not promises: installation quality, attic ventilation, storms and upkeep all move the number for any one roof.

Think about how long you plan to stay. If this is your forever home, a metal roof may outlast your time in it, while an asphalt roof will likely need replacing at least once along the way. If you expect to move in a few years, a well-installed architectural shingle roofing system gives you a strong, attractive roof at a lower upfront cost. We install architectural shingles only, not the thinner three-tab kind.

Upfront cost vs long-term cost

Metal costs more to install than asphalt shingles. How much more depends on the metal, the panel style, the shape of your roof and the condition of the decking underneath. Over the long run, though, you may pay for two asphalt roofs in the time one metal roof lasts, and metal usually needs less upkeep in between. If you are comparing quotes, our guide to what drives the cost of a metal roof explains why prices vary so much from one company to the next. Financing is available upon credit approval.

Energy efficiency in a Tennessee summer

Metal reflects more of the sun's heat than most asphalt shingles, especially in lighter or reflective cool roof colors. That can ease the load on your air conditioning through a long Middle or East Tennessee summer. How much you save depends on the color you choose, your attic insulation and ventilation, and how your home is built, so be wary of anyone who promises a specific percentage. If solar panels are in your plans now or later, metal also makes a solid base for mounting them.

Durability: wind, fire, hail and dents

A properly fastened metal roof holds up well in strong wind, and it will not catch fire from sparks or embers. Large hail or a falling limb can still dent some metal, and softer metals such as aluminum and copper dent more easily than steel. Asphalt shingles can lose granules or crack in hail and can lift or tear in high wind, which is why shingle roofs need a look after major storms. Some insurance companies offer a discount for metal roofs, so it is worth asking your agent before you decide.

The metal roofing styles we install

Metal roofing is no longer just silver barn panels. We install three residential systems:

  • Exposed fastener panels: screwed through the face of the panel, the most common metal roof on homes in Middle Tennessee and the most budget-friendly option.
  • Standing seam: raised seams and concealed clips that let the panels move as temperatures change, with a clean, modern look and no exposed screws.
  • Metal shingles: metal formed to look like shingles, shake or slate, for a traditional look with the lifespan of metal.

Most come in a wide range of factory colors, including reflective ones. Our standing seam metal roof page compares all three systems side by side. If you are near one of our offices, see our pages on metal roofing in Lebanon, TN and metal roofing in Hardin Valley.

Closer view of the roof: rear exterior view of a single-story home with a metal roof, brick chimney, and a covered patio with outdoor seating

Curb appeal, resale value and recycling

The roof is one of the first things people notice about a house. Metal's clean lines and color choices can lift curb appeal, and buyers like a roof that will not need replacing any time soon. A new architectural shingle roof also helps a sale, at a lower cost, so the better choice depends on your timeline. On the environmental side, metal roofing often contains recycled metal, and it can be recycled at the end of its life, along with the scrap from your installation.

Common metal roofing myths

Myth: metal roofs are too loud. That was often true of old barn roofs nailed over open rafters. A residential metal roof goes over solid decking and underlayment, with attic insulation between the roof and your living space, so rain sounds much like it does on shingles.

Myth: a metal roof attracts lightning. The National Weather Service's lightning myths page is clear that height, shape and isolation decide where lightning strikes, and the presence of metal makes no difference. If lightning does strike, a metal roof will not burn.

Myth: metal roofs rust and fade. People picturing rusty, faded metal are usually thinking of old, unpainted barns. Quality residential metal has protective coatings and paint finishes designed to resist rust, fading and chalking for many years.

Myth: metal raises your utility bills. The opposite is more likely, because metal reflects more of the sun's heat. Read more in our post on metal roofing myths.

Why it helps to ask a roofer that installs both

A company that only installs shingles may downplay metal, and a metal-only company may do the same to asphalt. When one company installs both, you get the whole picture and a recommendation built around your home, your plans and your budget. Our motto is simple: repair when we can, replace when we should, and when it is time to replace, help you pick the roof that fits.

Get a free estimate on metal or shingles

We will walk you through the pros and cons of each material, show you colors and profiles, and give you a written proposal with any possible decking costs stated up front. For a replacement, we measure your roof from satellite imagery, send a written proposal, and look at the roof in person before install day, or sooner on request. Mobley Brothers is a GAF Master Elite residential contractor, and both offices are A+ rated by the Better Business Bureau in Lebanon and Knoxville. Call our Lebanon office at (615) 455-3131 for Middle Tennessee or our Knoxville office at (865) 205-0800 for East Tennessee, or request a free estimate online.

Request a free estimate

A few details help us send the right person. If water is coming in right now, call instead.

Trusted like family.

Tell us what you are seeing. We will find the real problem.

Free estimates, photos of what we find, and a written proposal before any work starts. Open 24 hours, 7 days a week, with calls answered or returned day or night. On-site response depends on weather and safe working conditions.

Middle TennesseeLebanon office

(615) 455-3131
112 Tirzah Street, Lebanon, TN 37087

DirectionsBBB profile

East TennesseeKnoxville office

(865) 205-0800
10440 Laurel Pointe Lane, Knoxville, TN 37931

DirectionsBBB profile

Get a free estimate